Broil King vs Weber: Battle of the Grills

5/5 - (1 vote)

In this piece, Broil King and Weber, two of the most well-known brands of barbecue equipment in North America, square off against one another. We will evaluate and contrast some of the most well-known gas grills that these two industry leaders have to offer.

We believe that by providing you with some basic information about each brand, we can assist you in determining whether or not the items they sell are suitable for your needs.

Broil King

Onward Manufacturing Company is the parent company of the Broil King barbeque brand, which is a subsidiary of the company. Since its founding in 1906, Onward has been wholly owned and operated by Canadians. Its subsidiary, Broil King, has been in business for more than three decades.

The production of high-quality gas grills is the core emphasis of Broil King’s commercial operations. Their barbecues have had massive success in the Canadian market, where millions of units have been sold, and are beginning to make headway in the American market as well.

Broil King takes great satisfaction in offering grills that were manufactured in North America. Both Waterloo, Ontario and Huntington, Indiana are home to factories that produce gas grills. In order to keep up with the rising demand, they have equipped each of its locations with sizable and productive production facilities.


George Stephen, who was working at Weber Brother Metal Works in Chicago in 1952 when he came up with the idea for the “kettle” grill, is credited with being the inventor of Weber grills. The form of a buoy served as a source of motivation for him.

Today, Weber is recognized as one of the most prominent producers of gas grills available on the market (alongside numerous other products and types of grills).

The innovation that first assisted Weber in the development of the “buoy” grill is now a primary priority for the company, and they continue to uphold their dedication to high quality manufacturing and performance.

Weber vs. Broil King – Top Gas Grills

Both Broil King and Weber provide a vast selection of products in their respective product lines. In this piece, we’re going to zero in on one of their product lines, the gas grill, since it’s by far their most popular offering overall.

In North America, gas grills are by far the most common and widely used form of barbecue grill. It is not difficult to see why these grills continue to have such a dominant position in the market in North America given their reputation for greater convenience, consistent cooking, and simple cleaning.

We’ll be taking a look at two of the most popular gas grills available from both Broil King and Weber. Each of these grills is geared at a customer demographic that is comparable to the one they are targeting. First, we’ll provide an overview of each grill, and then we’ll go over the individual benefits that come with using each different brand.

Where to begin? How about with Broil King:

Broil King Gas Grills

1. Broil King Regal

To begin, let’s take a look at the Broil King Regal. This grill is promoted as the “premium” product offering that Broil King has to offer. It just takes a moment to see why this is the case, and we’re not just talking about the price tag here.

We have provided a link to the Regal S590, which is one of the most well-liked models in the Regal product line. However, it is crucial to remember that there are many other models available within the Regal product line.

The Broil King Regal is a formidable piece of outdoor cooking equipment. It has the capacity to cook for large gatherings of people, such as family reunions and parties, thanks to its burner that is rated at 55,000 BTU and its major cooking area that is 625 square inches. In addition, there is a side burner with 10,000 BTUs and a rotisserie grill with 15,000 BTUs.

This grill has a really amazing construction. Burners and a cooking system constructed entirely of stainless steel (Flav-R-Wave) are included into its construction. Stainless steel is a superb material for maintaining heat, which is necessary for producing those distinctive searing markings, and for ensuring that food is cooked evenly and consistently from front to back (with fewer “hot spots”).

This one has five burners, but the Regal may come with anything from four to six burners, giving you the maximum amount of flexibility.

The Regal is, without a doubt, one of the most spectacular and thoughtfully built gas burning grills that can be found on the market today. Massive amounts of utility, an excellent design made of stainless steel, and adequate amounts of heat retention and control. The cost is steep, but for someone who is passionate about grilling, it might very well be money well spent.


  • Main burner, side burner, and rotisserie grill.
  • An impressive 55,000 BTUs on main burner.
  • Impressive stainless-steel cooking grid design for ultimate durability and heat retention capabilities.
  • Sleek look with “aerodynamic” design.


  • Premium model – high price tag.
  • Purchase options may get a little overwhelming.

2. Broil King Baron

The Broil King Baron is up next for us to consider. In compared to the Regal, the Baron is considered to be more of a middle-tier alternative; nonetheless, it still has quite an astounding set of functionalities. It is one of Broil King’s best-selling products because it provides outstanding performance at a price that is easy on the wallet.

Again, there are numerous Barons that can be purchased, but the 922154 is the one that we have decided to emphasize.

The Broil King Baron is equipped with two tube burners made of stainless steel, each of which is capable of producing up to 40,000 BTUs. This model has a total floor space of 444 sq. in. of major room for cooking, with 644 square feet in. if you add the area on the upper racks, the entire amount of cooking space.

It has a build that is rather remarkable. The cast iron used to make the cooking grids is of the heavy-duty kind. However, the stainless-steel grids that come with the Broil King Regal are superior in terms of heat retention as well as the consistency of the cooking they provide. The grill itself is solidly constructed and long-lasting thanks to its metal construction; in addition, it has shelves made of stainless steel that can be folded down.

Flav-R-Wave cooking system ensures consistent temperatures across the grill; however, we always recommend using a meat thermometer for the best possible results. Temperature can be easily controlled with 180-degree control knobs; additionally, temperature can be maintained consistently across the grill.

This grill, in comparison to the Regal, has an overall design that is quite a bit simpler. But if all you need is a grill that is reliable, long-lasting, and capable of executing its functions, then the Baron could be all you want.

Even while it does not have as much power as the Regal and does not have as many functions, it is still an amazing grill that provides consistent cooking rates and temperatures.


  • Powerful, spacious primary cooking area.
  • Easy and predictable temperature control with 180-degree control knobs.
  • Cast-iron grids for ample heat retention.
  • Durable metal design with stainless-steel shelves.
  • Cost-effective solution.


  • Lacks much of the functionality of the Regal (side burners, stainless-steel grids, etc.)
  • You might need a bigger grill for large parties or gatherings.

Weber Gas Grills

1. Weber Summit Series

Moving on to Weber barbecues, the Weber Summit Series is the company’s most premium line of barbecue equipment, so let’s begin with that. Consider the Summit Series to be Weber’s answer to the Regal in terms of its grill line.

In point of fact, the Summit Series is positioned as an alternative that is a little bit more premium than the Regal, and its price point reflects this positioning.

Weber provides a wide variety of variations within each product range, much as Broil King does with its grills. The Summit S-470 has been brought to your attention.

The Summit is a pretty excellent piece of outdoor cooking equipment. This one has a main cooking surface that is 580 square inches in size and is powered by 48,800 BTUs.

The cooking grates are made of stainless steel, which has superior heat retention and far fewer “hot spots” than other materials. Burners are also constructed out of stainless steel, which not only makes them very long-lasting but also makes them highly resistant to rust and corrosion.

This particular model has four burners, but it is possible to purchase versions with as many as six burners (at progressively higher prices, of course!).

When compared to other grills, the Summit provides an exceptional amount of control for its users. Each burner is equipped with a Snap-Jet ignition mechanism, and the completely turning knobs make it possible to precisely adjust the temperature throughout the whole grilling area.

Additionally, there are a ton of other features included with this grill. It is equipped with a Sear Station burner, a smoker burner, and a rotisserie burner that is located in the back of the unit. Even while the smokers won’t allow for the full capabilities of a traditional charcoal smoker, it is still possible to cook a wide variety of foods with them. Its exceptionally extensive variety of functionalities is without a doubt its most significant advantage over rival products on the market.

In general, the Summit is a pretty nice grill, but it comes with a price tag that is very considerable. Even when contrasted with the Regal, this grill is in a class of its own. Therefore, if you are seeking for a grill that can handle everything, this one can be worth the price for you.


  • Big cooking surface with 48,800 BTUs of primary power.
  • Stainless steel grid and burner design.
  • Painted steel frame for durability and sleekness.
  • Huge range of functionality – side burners, Sear Station burner, smoker burner, and rotisserie burner.


  • Big price tag.
  • Not as many BTUs as the Regal.

2. Weber Genesis II Series

Following that, we will discuss the Weber Genesis II Series. The Genesis II Series is considered to be Weber’s mid-tier product offering. It is most analogous to the Broil King Baron, which is located above it in the product hierarchy. In this particular area, we have decided to put the spotlight on the Genesis II S-335.

The capabilities of this grill are quite remarkable. It has a cooking area that is 513 square inches in size and is equipped with three burners to evenly disperse heat throughout the surface. It comes with the high-performance grilling technology that Weber calls the Gs4 grilling system. In addition to being situated on the grilling surface, the Sear Station provides a high-heat zone that may be used to give food grill markings and to sear it.

This model, in contrast to the Broil King Baron, is equipped with a side burner. When it comes to cooking, it works well for either sautéing or simmering.

In general, it’s a well-made and practical grilling device. Rapid heating, excellent temperature control, and dependable performance features. It does not have nearly as many features as the Summit Series does, which is to be anticipated from a product that is placed in the middle tier. Affordability, dependability, and consistency in grilling are the hallmarks of this model, which is modeled after the Broil King Baron.


  • Spacious cooking area with 3 burners.
  • Stainless-steel burners are durable and corrosion-resistant.
  • Includes Sear Station and side burner.


  • Cast-iron grid is not as efficient at heat retention as stainless steel.
  • Not as powerful as comparable Broil King grills (in terms of BTUs).

Broil King vs. Weber – Gas Grills

Now that we’ve taken a look at two of the most popular grills manufactured by Broil King and Weber, you may be wondering: which one is superior?

In order to provide an answer to this issue, we will investigate each brand’s benefits in turn and identify the areas in which they have a distinct advantage over the other options. After that, we’ll provide our final thoughts and findings.

Advantages of Broil King

If you couldn’t tell from our product overviews up there, we consider grills manufactured by both manufacturers to be of a high caliber. Having saying that, there are undoubtedly certain things that Broil King does better.

To begin, the power of a Broil King grill is often higher than that of other brands. This results in an increase in BTUs. For the sake of comparison, the main burner on the Broil King Regal has 55,000 BTUs, whereas the primary burner on the Summit only has 48,800 BTUs.

Each brand is pretty comparable to one another in regard to the structure. Cast iron alternatives are available at the lower and middle price points, while stainless steel versions are available at the top end of both categories. Both brands of grills are exceptionally long-lasting and have solid builds.

In general, we believe that Broil King provides better performance than its competitors. They do not provide the extensive variety of features that are available on Weber grills because they have chosen to concentrate on producing a grill that is both powerful and reliable in its operation. To get the most value for your money, we recommend going with a Broil King grill since it heats up rapidly and maintains its temperature well.

Buy a Broil King If:

  • You desire a greater return on your investment of electricity.
  • You should look for a grill that has a greater focus on performance that is both consistent and dependable.
  • You are looking for a grill that is reliable in terms of its quality and performance and comes from a reputable brand.

Advantages of Weber

The majority of the characteristics of Broil King that were described above will still apply to Weber. Both manufacturers provide grills that are trustworthy, consistent, and constructed to demanding standards, which is something that we cannot refute. When we compare the most important aspects of each of them, we soon find ourselves engaging in pointless nitpicking. However, there are situations when it is vital to choose one option over the other.

In light of the above, it is safe to say that Weber has the upper hand when it comes to the variety of features. To provide one specific example, the Genesis Series, which is the counterpart of Weber’s Baron, comes equipped with a side burner, but the Broil King Baron does not. The same thing happened when comparing the Summit to the Regal, with the Summit having a greater number of features and burners than the Regal.

When compared to Broil King grills, Weber grills often provide a greater variety of features, despite the fact that Weber grills are more costly overall. And despite the fact that Broil King marginally outperforms Weber in terms of power and performance, the gap is not that significant.

Buy a Weber If:

  • You need a barbecue that has more options and accessories (more burners, cook stations, etc.).
  • You are unconcerned about the increased cost.
  • You want a grill that is reliable, of great quality, and performs very well (both of these things are offered by both companies!).

Top Brand + Product

Of course, the grill that is ideal for you is the one that satisfies your own tastes to the greatest extent possible. Have a look at the product descriptions we’ve provided up above, and see if any of them satisfy your product “wants.” In this manner, you will be able to choose the option that is most beneficial to you!

Having said that, the brand of gas grill that we use and recommend the most is Broil King. Simply said, Broil King provides greater value for the money, and we do not believe the added capability offered by Weber is sufficient to justify the price difference between the two brands.

Nevertheless, as was said before, both of these choices are premium, high-quality products; hence, there is no “wrong” alternative to choose.